Paid Ads vs Organic Social: What’s Best for Lead Generation in Shrewsbury & Shropshire?

If you’re a business owner in Shrewsbury or across Shropshire, you’ll know how important it is to generate leads that actually convert. But here’s the big question we hear all the time:

👉 Should you put your energy (and budget) into paid ads or organic social media?

Both can be powerful. Both can deliver results. But the way they do it and how quickly can be very different. Let’s break it down in a clear way so you can make the right choice for your business.

Paid Ads – The Quick Win

Think of paid ads as switching on a tap: once your campaign goes live, you’ll see your brand in front of people instantly.

Why they work:

• 🎯 Precision targeting – You can target people in Shrewsbury, Telford, or across Shropshire, even down to job titles or interests.
• ⚡ Speed – Ads can generate leads within hours, perfect if you need quick results.
• 📊 Measurable ROI – Every click and conversion can be tracked.

💡 Stat check: PPC lead generation in the UK can cost anywhere from £25–£250 per lead, depending on your industry and targeting strategy (ppcleadgeneration.co.uk).

Organic Social – The Trust Builder

Now let’s flip it. Organic social is all about building relationships through consistent, creative content. Think of it like planting seeds-it takes longer, but it grows stronger.

Why it matters:

• 🤝 Builds trust & loyalty – Customers see you as more than an advert.
• 🌱 Sustainable growth – Posts, blogs, and videos live on and continue to attract traffic long after they’re published.
• 💸 Cost-effective – Once your systems are in place, ongoing costs are minimal compared to ads.

💡 Stat check: Organic search generates the most leads for 27% of marketers, while 20% say social media is their top source (Exploding Topics).

The Smartest Approach? Use Both.

Here’s the truth: it’s not about choosing one or the other. Paid ads and organic social are strongest together.

• Paid ads = fast results, instant visibility.
• Organic = long-term trust, compounding growth.

In fact, research shows organic strategies can generate around 25% higher ROI over time than PPC alone (Salience). So why not combine both and get the best of both worlds?

FAQs

Q: Do paid ads hurt our organic performance?
Not at all. Paid ads can actually boost organic results by increasing awareness, which leads to more searches and organic clicks.

Q: Which is cheaper in the long run?
Organic wins here. While it takes longer, the ROI compounds over time. Paid ads stop working the moment you stop paying.

Q: What’s happening with organic reach?
Organic reach is declining on platforms like Facebook and Instagram (Addictive Digital), which is why combining paid ads with strong organic content is the best strategy.

Our Advice for Shropshire Businesses

Here’s the approach we use with clients:

1. Start small with paid ads – Target Shrewsbury or wider Shropshire postcodes with clear, compelling campaigns.
2. Build organic consistency – Share creative content that shows your personality and value.
3. Track, test, and tweak – Paid gives you instant data; organic builds the bigger picture.
4. Grow steadily – Use ads for quick wins and organic for long-term success.

Ready to Generate Leads the Smart Way?

At Evolve My Media, we help Shropshire businesses find the perfect balance between paid ads and organic social. If you’re unsure where to put your time and budget, let’s chat. Together, we’ll design a strategy that delivers leads today.

👉 Book a call with us today

‍