AI vs The Algorithm: What Instagram Really Prioritises in 2025

Instagram in 2025 feels like a battlefield:
Creators vs brands.
Content vs competition.
AI tools vs the algorithm that seems to change every five minutes.

With the rise of AI-generated content on Instagram, many businesses are asking the same question:
“What does Instagram actually prioritise now - the algorithm, or AI-powered creation?”

The answer isn’t as obvious as you’d think.

In this blog, we break down what Instagram is really looking for this year, how AI is reshaping the platform, and what your business should do to stay ahead (especially if you’re a small business in Shrewsbury or anywhere across Shropshire trying to grow).

Let’s get into it - without the fluff.

⭐ First: Instagram’s Algorithm Isn’t the Enemy

Instagram’s 2025 algorithm isn’t trying to punish you.
It’s trying to predict what users will find valuable - and keep them on the app longer.

According to Instagram’s official 2024 Creator Report:

• The platform ranks content on interest, relevance and behaviour, not follower count.
• The average user now scrolls 23% more short-form video per day than in 2023.
  (Source: Instagram @Creators, 2024)

Meaning?
Instagram prioritises impact, not format.

But where does AI fit into this?

⭐ AI Is Everywhere - But Instagram Has Mixed Feelings About It

AI content exploded in 2024. Tools like ChatGPT, Midjourney, Runway and CapCut AI templates made it easier than ever for brands to create content fast.

Instagram’s stance in 2025 is very clear:

Instagram does NOT prioritise AI content - it prioritises content that performs.

If AI helps you:

• Create better Reels
• Improve your hooks
• Speed up editing
• Enhance storytelling

…then Instagram will reward the result, not the method.

But if AI:

• Feels generic
• Lacks personality
• Looks templated
• Creates “spammy” content

…Instagram deprioritises it.

This aligns with the platform’s announcement in late 2024 that it would reduce reach for “low-effort or repetitive formats.”
(Source: Meta Transparency Centre, 2024)

So the rule is simple:
AI is a tool - not a shortcut.

⭐ What Instagram Actually Prioritises in 2025

Let’s break down the real ranking signals that matter this year:

1️⃣ Watch Time (The Biggest Factor for Reels)

If someone watches your Reel for longer than 3 seconds, you win.
If they rewatch it, you win even harder.

Instagram uses watch time to judge:

• Quality
• Relevance
• Retention

High watch time = pushed to more people.

What increases watch time in 2025?

• Strong hooks (first 2 seconds)
• Fast pacing
• Relatable storytelling
• Face-forward content
• “Oh WOW” moments
• Tutorials under 20 seconds

AI can help with scripting and editing, but human presence still performs best.

2️⃣ Saves (The New Super Engagement)

Photos may have lost a bit of reach, but they still dominate in saves, which Instagram treats as the strongest long-term signal.

Carousels are especially powerful.

Educational content = saves
Guides = saves
Lists = saves
Before/after transformations = saves

AI can help design carousels - but authenticity still wins.

3️⃣ Shares (Huge in 2025)

Instagram’s algorithm LOVES shares because they indicate:

• Social proof
• Real-world relevance
• High value

Reels and graphics with strong messages often drive the most shares.

4️⃣ Original Content (Even When AI-Assisted)

Meta confirmed in Q1 2024 that “original content is more likely to be recommended.”
(Source: Meta Engineering Blog, 2024)

This does not mean "no AI allowed."
It means:

• Add personality
• Add commentary
• Add unique visuals
• Add your brand’s flavour

AI can help produce - but it can’t replicate you.

5️⃣ Community Interactions (DMs Matter More Than Likes Now)

Instagram now uses:

• DM replies
• Story interactions
• Poll responses
• Link clicks

…as core ranking signals.

This shift means you must create content that sparks conversation, not just “double taps.”

AI doesn’t create community.
You do.

⭐ AI vs The Algorithm: Who Actually Wins?

Here’s the truth Instagram doesn’t explicitly say:

AI helps you win if you stay authentic.

AI hurts you if you replace authenticity.**

The businesses performing best in 2025 are using AI for:

• Speed
• Structure
• Editing
• Scripts
• Efficiency

But they are using human creativity for:

• Ideas
• Storytelling
• Hooks
• On-camera delivery
• Brand voice

Instagram’s algorithm prioritises:

• Relevance
• Emotion
• Value
• Human-led creativity

…none of which AI can replicate fully.

AI can accelerate the process - but it can’t replace the personality behind it.

⭐ What This Means for Businesses in 2025

If you’re managing your own social media, here’s the part you’ll want to screenshot:

The winning formula for 2025 is:

**AI-assisted creativity

• Human-led storytelling
• Algorithm-friendly formats
  = Maximum reach + trust + conversions**

Businesses who rely only on AI will blend in.
Businesses who rely only on themselves will burn out.
Businesses who combine both will win.

And that’s exactly what agencies like Evolve My Media help brands do - blend smart technology with creative strategy that actually performs.

⭐ FAQs: AI vs Instagram Algorithm (2025)

Does Instagram penalise AI content?

No - only low-quality or repetitive content.

Do Reels made with AI templates perform worse?

Not if the hook, pacing and story are strong.

Will AI replace social media managers?

No. It will replace tasks, not strategy.

What matters more in 2025: AI tools or understanding the algorithm?

Understanding the algorithm.
AI just helps you move faster.

⭐ Final Thoughts: AI Isn’t the Strategy - You Are.

Instagram in 2025 isn’t about choosing between AI or the algorithm.
It’s about knowing how to use both strategically.

• Use AI to speed things up.
• Use your creativity to stand out.
• Use algorithm insights to scale.

If you get those three working together, Instagram becomes a predictable, powerful growth engine - not a guessing game.

And if you want help turning Instagram into something that actually drives leads, not just likes…

⭐ Ready to level up your Instagram strategy?

At Evolve My Media, we help businesses across Shrewsbury and Shropshire use AI properly while building content systems that align with Instagram’s algorithm - not work against it.

If you want clarity, strategy and content that actually converts, book a free discovery call.

👉 Click here to book your discovery call with Evolve My Media.

‍